Surveys and trial and error guide programs for young people ages 16 to 24
When Brooklyn Community Services asked the young people in its programs what they needed, they answered in numbers that surprised its leader. “It was an impressive amount of responses,” said Archana Jayaram, Executive Director of Brooklyn Community Services (BCS). “It gave me the sense that there was gratitude for being asked.”
The survey reached teens and young adults across the organization’s programs, from community centers to supportive housing for young people aging out of foster care. Their answers are pushing BCS to rethink how it offers support, starting with one simple idea. Let young people lead.
Mental health goes beyond the therapist’s office
One finding stood out to Jayaram. Young people see their mental health as tied to the pressures around them.
“Young people think about mental health in a more expansive way than typically we have,” she said. “They think about things that influence their mental health, like stress and anxiety and instability and social problems, as a core part of their mental health.”
“They’re thinking about the upstream and the downstream,” she added. “They have an understanding of where there are outside forces that are impacting their mental health.”
BCS already runs mental health programs for young people inside its community centers. Jayaram noted that teens who use them make a choice to show up.
“You’re not going to get that service directly in your school,” she said. “You’re going to have to leave and go somewhere else. A lot of young people make the choice to do that because they’re looking for that kind of support and community.”
Sometimes teens just want a safe place to be
The survey also showed that support does not always mean conversation.
“Sometimes they want to talk and sometimes they don’t want to talk,” Jayaram said. “Sometimes they just want to be in a space where they can be safe, where they’re not on the street, where there’s an adult, but they don’t necessarily want to say, ‘I’m feeling bad and this is why.’”
That feedback challenged the way many programs work.
“With a lot of our programs, it’s like, great, let’s get in there, let’s talk it out,” she said. “And they’re like, sometimes we’re not ready to talk. And that’s super helpful feedback for us to understand.”
Some teens also asked for help that does not require walking through a door. They want talk therapy, but they also want computer-based and remote options.
“Some of us might think that in-person is better, but the first step is to get people to the table,” Jayaram said. “If somebody is telling you, ‘I’d like to get your services, but I don’t want to physically go to your site,’ we have to create an option for that.”
Programs built on trial and error
Listening guides how BCS runs its community centers across Brooklyn, including sites inside NYCHA developments. For young adults ages 16 to 24, Jayaram said the method is simple.
“The main thing is to ask them,” she said. “It’s just to say, ‘What are you looking for? What are the kinds of things that would bring you to this program?’”
Program directors then test ideas and watch how young people respond.
“They’re saying, ‘OK, let’s try a movie night,’” she said. “And the movie night doesn’t work, let’s say. So they’re like, ‘OK, that was a good try, let’s try something else.’”
When BCS surveyed its frontline staff, they echoed much of what young people said.
“Everyone’s kind of on the same page if you are working with this population,” Jayaram said. “And there’s a lot more commonality than you might expect.”
Why asking matters
For Jayaram, the survey confirmed something BCS has practiced since its founding 160 years ago. The organization looks at its community, asks who needs support and builds from there.
“If you let the young people lead the way, then they are going to tell you what they need,” she said. “And then they’re going to be responsive when we’re responsive to them.”
People can donate or volunteer at wearebcs.org and follow @wearebcs on social media.