← Back to Live Feed
Florida coin toss decides a city race after a perfect tie
Rolling Out November 20, 2026
Entertainment

Florida coin toss decides a city race after a perfect tie

Listen to Story Narration
Click play for AI audio summary
AUDIO

⚡ BLK.news Key Takeaways

How did the Atlantic Beach coin toss election get tied? On Nov. 4, the day after the election, Herrold held a razor-thin lead of 3,156 votes to Lagner’s 3,154. The state allows ties to be resolved by lot, and a coin toss counts as a game of chance. What did the candidates say after the coin toss election? Why does the Atlantic Beach coin toss election matter?

A coin toss election in Atlantic Beach shows how much one skipped choice can matter

A coin toss decided the race for Seat 4 on the Atlantic Beach City Commission in Florida after Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold each finished with exactly 3,162 votes following machine and manual recounts. Lagner won the best two out of three toss outside the Duval County Supervisor of Elections office in Jacksonville on Friday, Nov. 13, taking both of the first two flips. The whole thing took about 20 seconds.

Sponsored Report

The tie nearly broke at the last minute. Election officials received one more overseas ballot on Nov. 12, but when they opened it, the voter had left the Atlantic Beach commission race blank. One skipped choice on one ballot sent the race to chance.

How did the Atlantic Beach coin toss election get tied?

The lead kept moving. On Nov. 4, the day after the election, Herrold held a razor-thin lead of 3,156 votes to Lagner’s 3,154. Recounts were ordered when unofficial tallies showed Herrold ahead 3,160 to 3,158. At another point, with 6,311 votes counted, Herrold led by a single vote. On Nov. 9, Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland announced the machine and manual recount had been paused.

Officials waited on late ballots before the toss. Holland said overseas ballots postmarked on or before Election Day had until that Friday to be counted. When the final eligible ballot came in blank for this race, the numbers stayed locked at 3,162 each.

How did the coin toss work?

The rules were set ahead of time. Holland used his office’s challenge coin, and each flip had to land in the center of a square mat to count. Each candidate called one of the first two tosses. Herrold called heads first, and the coin landed tails. Lagner then called heads, and the coin landed heads, giving her two wins and the seat.

Is a coin toss legal in a Florida election?

Yes. Under Florida state law, a tied race like this one is decided by chance. The state allows ties to be resolved by lot, and a coin toss counts as a game of chance. Duval County has done this before. In 2014, a tied Neptune Beach City Council race was settled with numbered ping pong balls. Holland called this only the second tied election in the county’s history.

What did the candidates say after the coin toss election?

Both handled it with grace. Lagner told Action News Jax the moment showed how great and free the country is, and she later thanked Holland and his team on Facebook, calling the coin toss an unexpected and unforgettable way to end an election. Herrold said she and Lagner have both been part of the community for years and that they would look back on how unbelievable it all was. Holland said the outcome proves every vote matters and that one vote can make a difference.

Why does the Atlantic Beach coin toss election matter?

It is the clearest proof of what one ballot can do. More than 6,300 people voted in this race, and it still came down to chance. Local elections for city commission, school board and county seats often draw far fewer voters than national races, even though they decide everyday things like roads, parks and policing. Anyone who has ever skipped a local race, or skipped voting altogether, now has a coin in Florida to think about.