A doula's own delivery became a fight against medical coercion and race bias
Cherise Doyley is a birth worker, doula educator and birth justice advocate who has spent years protecting the autonomy of Black and marginalized families. As the founder of Soul Sista Birth Services, she has trained doulas and supported families navigating the healthcare system. Her advocacy took on new urgency in 2024, when she found herself laboring while a judge, appearing over a tablet, was brought in to decide whether she would be forced to undergo a C-section.
Pressured from the moment she arrived
Doyley walked into UF Health Jacksonville believing her care team supported her plan for a trial of labor after three prior cesareans. Instead, she said, “it felt like I was in gang territory, because they were constantly trying to force me to have a C-section despite there not being any distress in me or the baby.” A psychiatrist was sent to evaluate her, telling her she had heard Doyley was suicidal, a claim Doyley says she never made. “I was so floored because I had never said anything like that.”
A fair hearing denied
Like many facing this situation, Doyley had no lawyer while the hospital and state had attorneys present. “It was very scary, it was disheartening,” she said. “To have that choice taken away from me and also not be allowed to be represented in a way that would give me a fair hearing was honestly very terrifying.” Doyley, who understood the medical risks better than most as a doula and midwife, also asked for a Black provider during her hearing, a request she says was denied. “They told me that they didn’t think that race had anything to do with it, despite the astronomical Black maternal mortality rates in this country.”
No real emergency
During the three-hour hearing, Doyley used her professional knowledge to dismantle the hospital’s claims. “I was able to use the knowledge that I have as a doula and a midwife to break down those claims that they brought, and ultimately get them to admit that there was no emergency,” she said, calling it a case brought “under false pretenses.”
An armed guard and a lasting toll
Doyley described an armed guard posted outside her door as terrifying. “It felt like I was in a movie, like I was being held hostage, I was trapped,” she said. “My whole family was literally afraid.” The day after birth, doctors recommended a full hysterectomy following a high transverse incision. “I was only 30 years old at the time, so I don’t know how many more children that I may have had,” she said. Doyley says she now lives with PTSD, depression and Bell’s palsy stemming from the ordeal. “I feel like I lost a part of me that day that I can’t really put into words.”
Turning trauma into advocacy
Despite the toll, Doyley continues to advocate for other Black mothers. “Advocate like your life depends on it, because it does,” she said. “You don’t have to have a medical degree to have a say-so in your care.” She is raising funds through a GoFundMe to support her family and the cost of ongoing litigation.
Doyley’s story is a reminder that every birthing person has the right to be heard and to make informed choices about their own body. Readers can follow her journey on Instagram at @doula_cherise, learn more about her doula training and family support through Soul Sista Birth Services, and contribute to her GoFundMe to help cover her family’s needs and the cost of ongoing litigation.