Thomas Markle’s competency hearing could pause his case, but one expert says it is no free pass
Thomas Markle Sr., the 82-year-old estranged father of Meghan, the Duchess of Sussex, was due in federal court in Tampa, Florida, this afternoon, Nov. 19, for a hearing on whether he is mentally fit to stand trial. He faces one federal count of possessing child sexual abuse material and has denied the allegations, calling them lies.
The hearing will help decide whether his case moves toward trial or pauses while doctors evaluate him. If convicted, he faces up to 20 years in federal prison, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office.
Why is Thomas Markle having a competency hearing?
A judge raised concerns at his first court appearance. U.S. Magistrate Judge Lindsay Griffin wrote that information about his health, his advanced age and his lack of recall gave her reasonable cause to believe he may not be able to understand the proceedings or help with his own defense. She appointed forensic psychiatrist Dr. Amie Gerodimos to examine him and report back to the court by Nov. 20.
Markle has a long list of health problems. He had heart attacks around the time of Meghan’s 2018 wedding to Prince Harry, suffered a stroke while living in the Philippines and had his left leg amputated. He was living in a Florida care home that specializes in dementia when the FBI arrested him on Nov. 6.
What happens if Thomas Markle is found unfit for trial?
That is the part many people misunderstand. Neama Rahmani, president of West Coast Trial Lawyers, told Newsweek that being ruled incompetent is not a free pass. He said a defendant found unfit generally stays in custody until he can assist in his defense, and that mental decline is not a legal defense to knowingly possessing illegal material, though it could matter at sentencing.
What is Thomas Markle accused of?
Federal prosecutors say agents seized about 78 items, including slides, film negatives and books containing suspected child sexual abuse material, from two Los Angeles-area storage units Markle rented for nearly two decades. They allege some of the material shows Markle himself with minors. Federal officials have said they will prosecute the case to the fullest extent of the law.
The investigation began after The Sun reported in October that Markle’s son, Tom Markle Jr., had found troubling material while clearing out their father’s home in the Philippines and reported it to police there. Markle told the Daily Mail at the time that he welcomed an investigation and could never do what he was accused of.
Why is Thomas Markle in jail now?
After his first hearing, where no plea was entered, the judge released him on his own recognizance under home detention with electronic monitoring. Four days later, on Nov. 10, he was ordered back to jail after authorities accused him of cutting off his ankle monitor. He is being held pending trial. He is represented by a federal public defender in Tampa.
He also faces trouble overseas. Philippine police filed a formal criminal complaint against him this week after examining digital devices from his former home in Cebu City, and prosecutors there will decide whether to bring charges.
What has Meghan said about her father’s case?
Meghan, who has been estranged from her father since her wedding, has not commented publicly since his arrest. When the allegations first surfaced, she said she was deeply distressed and that her thoughts were with any children who may have been harmed. She also said British police had given her a letter in 2019 raising similar accusations against him.
Whatever the court decides about Markle’s mind, the case centers on children who cannot speak for themselves. Markle is presumed innocent, and the charges have not been proven.
If you know of a child being harmed or see suspected child sexual abuse material online, report it to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children’s CyberTipline at report.cybertip.org or call the Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline at 1 800 422 4453.